I did not like the smell when I first used it. I appreciated it more as the day wore on. It doesn't have the typical rose smell. I'm not sure how to describe other than it smells like the cousin of a rose with the pink pepper undertone. Positives are it's a unique and distinctive scent that lasts all day.

Luv this perfume. Sweeet

I actually love this scent over the more popular designer fragrances. My daughter thinks it smells a little old fashioned, but I love it and I'm an 80's baby.

It’s a little too mature for my liking. It does eventually wear down to a nice powdery fragrance

I did not like the smell

I’ve never had a floral smelling scent before so I thought “why not”, I smelled like a bed of roses and I ain’t mad. The kinda scent that lasts all day long. If more floral smelling scents ain’t your bag then this isn’t for you.

I love it. I would buy the full bottle

I love this scent. With my chemistry it works really well. It does come across as a very classic and classy rose scent. Pepper and passionfruit in the top notes adds a little zing at the start but doesn't last long and then it is just roses, roses, roses for me with a very mellow oud base (Not usually a favorite for me but it gives this scent its staying power) with ambergris/ambrette musk for a touch of sexy sweetness. I love that this is so well balanced and no old-lady-powder scent for me here! This is fluid, decadently floral but with just a hint of animalaic. Love it.

If I could give a negative star or just no star at all, I would. This is the absolute worst perfume I have ever had the displeasure of smelling. It's too strong and smells water in vases full of dead roses. It doesn't get better either. I had friends try it to see if it got better with different body chemistry....it didn't. It reminds me of expired old lady perfume. Disgusting.

Didn't like this scent at all

OH MY!! Love this fragrance. Subtle. Not too strong. Yummmmmm...

I just wasn't sure about the combination of scents. I tried it several times and it just didn't work well for me. And it faded so quickly even if I had enjoyed the fragrance I would have had to reapply too many times during the day.

Way too strong for me. Not a bad smell, but not a plesent one. 🤷🏽‍♀️

I love roses, but this screams roses with alcohol... A lot of it. Way too strong for my taste. A bit disappointing, but I guess when you're sampling new scents, you're definitely going to win some and lose some. I must admit though, I like all the other ones I've received thus far. Can't wait to try my next shipments.... (Notice plural, **SHIPMENTS) I'm now 2 months behind in receiving my normal monthly shipments😣. Please hurry Scentbird🙏. I can't wait to receive my new ones❤

I love rose when it is done well, but this just hit my nose wrong and smelled like grandmas to me. not cute.

This perfume literally, and I mean LITERALLY, smelled like pickle juice. Its horrifying. Straight up pickles. Notes of rose? Nope, PICKLES.

Scent was too feminine.

Smells like roses. Not sure, what else you need to know. If you like roses, you'll probably like this.

I definitely liked this scent. The rose was nice. I would definitely wear on a few occasions, but all in all much too floral for me personally to just wear out any day. I would only wear this maybe to a wedding. Wouldn’t buy it. It’s on the lighter side of unisex. I liked it My sister loved it

The overwhelming rose/sweet smell of this is awful. I like floral perfumes but this is just too much! Makes me nauseous just smelling the vial of perfume, can’t imagine if I actually sprayed it on my skin. Going in the trash! 🤢

I didn’t like the smell

This just did not hit sny marks with me what so ever. It just reeked of old lady Grandma perfume

Smell is too sweet

I just love the scent its tart but also sweet reminds me of sour candy without being too sweet and foody.

Smells like a “grown up” version of VS’s lovespell. Sickly sweet and nasty. Very disappointed.

I generally lean toward fruity smells or smells like vanilla and the site said the main smells were orange, vanilla, and flowers (I forget which one specifically) but all I smell is a floral scent which is strong and almost like a stuffy grandma’s house. Like it actually reminds me of going to an elderly home and being suffocated with a tight perfume filled hug, by a woman named Eldridge. She’s a nice old lady and all but the scent is just so strong and gross.

Reminds me of a skunky kind of smell. Definetly not a good buy.

Smells like a cleaning product. But a cleaning product that is trying to cover up a bad smell with a overpowering chemical. I'm keeping this one in my gym bag so I can spray the inside of my shoes after working out.

This sent isn't as good as I thought it would be. I like strong scented perfume, but this one is strong in a bad way. Some notes need to be toned down and others visa versa. Its a nice scent overall but not worth paying full price for.

I like the other EB Florals, but I *hate* this one. Extremely heavy old-lady rose with some nasty funk underneath. Gives me a headache.

I got so many compliments from everyone who came in contact with me. The scent lasted all day long.

This perfume is just perfect. It is flowery in a good way. Not rosy but flowery. It’s refreshing. I feel its perfect. My husband, who dislikes strong scents, gave me a compliment when I wore it the first time. I love it even more. I font get a headache with it.

Not sure if I love it or not!! It’s nice and rosy just can’t decide if it’ll be an everyday scent.

Pretty strong

I Love it!

Rose and some generic citrus. The rose is beautiful, but the citrus cheapens it. I don't get vanilla or pepper at all. Not bad, but very safe with no complexity. No sillage and little staying power.

Hated it. Smelled like rotten juice. Thankfully it didnt last long.

I felt that the rose floral scent was too overpowering and didn't calm down the more it was worn for me. I think as a sachet, it would be perfect.

Great scent!!

I did not enjoy this one. I love florals but this one did not play well with my body chemistry. The scent fell flat when I applied it.

gross never get this one smells like a smelly old lady

I really liked this fragrance!! I like how it has a spicy bite mixed in with the roses. It smelled so good that I have ordered it for more that just one month!!

I really like this scent. it is very floral. I don't usually like florals.. but this on is very light and refreshing.

I went “queue happy” and started adding things to it and must’ve added this scent on accident because I’m not a rose scent person. I honestly don’t even think I added it since it had rose in the name... oh well, hope the next one is better lol

I love the scent. It stays all day and not over powering. Best scent ever!

The scent profile of this was amazing. It was lite and still carried the scent of gentle rose without smelling like grandmas potpourri.

I love floral scents and especially rose BUT this is not a pleasant smell AT ALL! Maybe it is too much pepper - not sure but I agree with one reviewer that it smelled like pickles!! I had to find some alcohol wipes to try and get it off of me.

I chose this one based on the suggested form the fragrances I like. Not good fit for me

Yech! I love other Eric Buterbaugh scents, but NOT this one! The rose note is pleasant, but it's accompanied by a very nasty collection of scents. I threw this one away.

This smell was horrible. I can't quite describe it, but it was a combination of soap and pepper. Super strong, sickly smell that's just not flattering at all.

Very strong overwhelming rose scent with a touch of old lady fragrance. It's ok once it settles for a while, but very weird when first sprayed.

Strong in scent, it reminds me of a flower shop or garden. Would have liked it to have lasted longer. I would pick the fall or definitely the winter.

I didnt like the smell at all it was overwhelming smell of flower rose mainly thats my fault dont know how to choose my scent

Not awful but smelled sickly. Rose frangrance, with a little too much of grandma’s basement smell mixed in. Mothballs maybe? Ick.

I personally felt this had an over whelming fragrance of 🌹 roses. Which I don’t care for. And it seemed heavy

Great selection if you are looking for the true "rose" scent. While the rose is definitely the top note, you still get the hint of the vanilla & pink pepper undertones. Try it when you want to feel fresh and romantic. Lasted on me for about 5 hours, on a hot day, when applied directly to skin so I would expect it to last all day if I applied over clothing.

Really wish I would have went with the Montale or anything else. It smells like pickles and while I love pickles. I don’t want to smell like them. Huge bummer :(

Love the light rosey scent! It has become my favorite!

I like it very much. Lasted a very long time.

Nice. I tend to enjoy Floral scents. But even this was a bit much for me.

This scent is so beautiful! Every time I wear it I get many compliments about how great I smell. The scent isn’t overwhelming. It’s fresh and simply pretty.

Did not like the the scent.

The perfume notes were mostly floral and lasted all day for me. I only had to put on two spritz and it lasted all day even in the heat.

I’m more of a vanilla girl. The Rose is the first note and to over powering. It dies down after awhile. It is still a beautiful scent for a floral lover.

To me, it is not a traditional rose smell. I can smell a little citrus and at the end the eucalyptus that make this a little zesty with the pink pepper. I am really in love with it <3 I just can't stop smelling myself. I am really happy I choose this scent. This will definitely be a permanent scent in my collection.

I very much enjoy this scent. This was my first shipment. I LOVE the holder...twisting like lipstick...sooo cute. My first thoughs were, "I need more than one scent a month and I need more of the vial holders." I would order more of this scent when it runs out. Floral with a hint of something else.

I absolutely loved this scent. It is perfect for summer! It clean and fresh smelling, no overpowering scent.

The thing that really stands out about this cologne is the smell of roses. I closed my eyes and I felt like I was smelling an actual rose. Perfect for special occasions.

its freaking gross a waste of 15 bucks , Can we return for a different frangrance? Its so strong like not a good strong like a bathroom scent or something ..gross

This perfume is so strong but not in the way you want. Isn’t rich and long lasting it’s a punch in the face, heavy smell which reminds me of a floral bathroom spray.

the smell is nice but there is a but smh... the burst of pepper will make anyone sneeze thats close by you... i had the whole venue sneezing just about, not a good look @ all... i will only use this for an outside event or a spare... smelling the pepper in this makes me shy away from fragrances with pepper in it...

there's a lot more Rose scent than i anticipated. It isn't as young and flirty of a scent as I wanted. Doesn't smell entirely bad, just not for me.

Really floral with a toothpaste aftersmell.

I love light floral scents but this has too much of something, my daughter and I both can’t even finish the bottle.

i LOVED this!!! I love rose but hate when its too sweet or strong. this smells amazing!!

I wanted to love this because I am a rose fan but it gives me a terrible headache. As others said its sickly sweet and I prefer more musk with my rose. This won't stay in my collection

The scent of rose stays with me all day with every movement. This is elegant and sexy and will definitely turns heads to get another smell of the aroma on you.

I like it

An unsubtle sweetness that punched me in the sinuses. I gave it time, but it didn't ease up at all.

Enjoyed this scent; has a soft floral scent. I would wear this every day. Had many complements on it.

There was something very sickly sweet about this scent that actually gave me a headache along with a dose of nausea...almost syrupy in a bad way. I couldn't hang- tossed it into a closet to be forgotten about. Next!

It’s a nice fragrance however it’s too rosy for me. I use it before bed for a lil something...but not outside.

I thought I would like it but I don’t.. I knew it was a flowery smell but it was too strong. New at this so now I know not to get floral smells.

I was impressed with the new rose scent it had a fruity pepper and cool different smell to it. A different refreshing smell. The notes that stood out are the rose at first as it settles a hint of pepper and vanilla, and then to a great pleasant floral fruity fragrance. A few hours into the day it does settle into a rose musk kind of smell. waiting to see how people react to it.

Was not happy with this scent as I love fruity smells but there seemed to be too much of something in it as it was very overpowering.

Seemed so intriguing, bit it has way to much pepper in it.

Most people don’t like the smell of mint a cinnamon together. But I thought it was delightfully elegant.

This is very nice sweet clean scent, great for spring

Rose-y, rose-y, and rose-y. This scent was too overpowering for my taste. My husband accidentally knocked the bottle to the floor, where it shattered...my home smelled like roses for a week.

Nice smell but doesnt last very long.

This is an amazing rose scent. It’s not your grandmas rose perfume. So if you are looking to smell like a sweet grandma look elsewhere. Thorns Rose perfume smells just like a fresh rose garden, elegant, fresh and green.

Like every perfume, the smell adjusts to your body chem. I loved my combination. Everyone would ask "what are you wearing?, it smells so good!" Out of the bottle I honestly was a little suspicious that it was too floral, but it really wasn't and the smell also lasts for a while.

Smelled sweet lol guys kept atopping me to say i smell great and familiar

Smell too sweet for me.

I'd absolutely send it back for free.. I don't even like to try smelling it again .. Not fresh, Not floral, Not nice at all. and I am a real floral-perfume person .. That has to change the name to anything but Rose.. :/ Big disappointment .. :( :( :(

This perfume was seeeter than I wanted and a little stronger too. I like a light subtle scent and I wouldn’t say this one was either light or subtle. Nice combination but too much for my taste.

With a combination of vanilla, rose, and citrus, I expected this perfume to be sweet and subtle. The scent is actually strong and almost tart smelling.

I like this perfume, but it’s a little too much when no one wears perfume around you. It’s a very good one for a night out, not for an everyday fragrance.

Love the smell of roses, reminds me of summer!

just so floral and amazing, i want the full size now!

Especially once it has settled, it has that waxy, cheap molded soap smell. Update: After a month or so, I've completely changed my mind on this! From soap initially, I now get raw, wet rose-the stems almost-just as it is named. I always feel that I over spray it (and probably do), but I love how bold yet not obnoxious this scent is. Not an everyday one for me (though it easily could be for someone else!) but definitely good to have in the arsenal. My first scentbird happy match :)

Something about this smells cheap and unpleasant. Reminds me of the scent public restroom soap leaves on your hands after you've washed them.

Great fresh soft smell.

I enjoyed this scent very much. Its woodsy, yet I can smell the roses. Its a clean, fresh scent.

It smells incredible. Like juicy rose and spices if that makes sense. It's very different from other rose perfumes I've had, which is nice because it's not just a repeat. It's really lovely. One of my new favorites.

I am pretty picky about scents but I decided to join to try new ones. I love this scent. It isn't like anything i have smelled before. I wouldn't consider it rosy, to me it is many lively scents mingled. I smell floral meets a hint of cinnamon and pepper.

I didn’t like it

I love floral perfumes. I love sweet perfumes. This...I don't even know what to say. When I was younger, I used to press flowers. One time, I tried pressing a whole rose. Unfortunately, it molded. This perfume reminds me of that. It reminds me of a molded rose where the sweet scent is kind of present but in a very sickening way. Everyone who smelled me wearing this perfume said it smells disgusting and offensive. On a positive note...it does last a long time.

Too much rose

I was hoping for a more balanced scent but this one was very heavy on the rose notes. Too fruity for me. Not a fan.

Smells like an old lady

At first I smelled brandy, eucalyptus and roses, which reminded me of an old-fashioned cough syrup. :) Then it turns into a more subtle mix of green notes and rose , evocative of torn petals and leaves. Not bad, different enough for me, it doesn't seem to last very long, though.

Top notes are just as if you’re walking into an amazing rose garden, fragrant and fresh, then it moves into a very sweet & warm space, via the tonka bean and vanilla. This is delightful in many ways and even though the scent of roses has always been categorized as feminine, I think this transcends genders for anyone willing to be more in tune with it.

This is warm darker scent.. not sweet or floral but very feminine. Not an everyday perfume. I wear it when I feel or need to feel empowered.

I would rather wear old lady perfume than this nasty scent. It smells sour and of a nauseatingly floral sweetness at the same time. Not my cup of tea. Very light and airy scent. Smells more like a cheap light floral body spray than a quality perfume.

This was my first scent and was not fond of it at all. I would not want this one again. Not for me. But not giving up. Received my second scent today and love it.

Not bad. So far only the second fragrance I've liked. It definitely has a rose and fruity scent so it's exactly as described. Can't fault it for that.

I love the scent, lota of compliments

Always adored the scent of roses. This perfume captures it to a T. Would love to get the regular size bottle.

The scent is beautiful. A nice soft fragrance. One of the best rose scents I have ever tried but it does not last. It seems to fade very quickly.

I loved this scent, it is unlike any other rose one I have tried. It's light but not too light - although it doesn't last as long on my skin as I would like, but lasted longer when I sprayed on my clothes - but still not very long. It's a great scent in the beginning but fades fast.

This scent is different for sure, I found that if spayed on skin it doesn't last to long but when sprayed on clothing it lasted much longer and is noticeable for sure.

This is an extremely close to the body scent with limited staying power. There is a quick impression of the eucalyptus when you first put it on. Then you quickly settle into a subtle green/rose scent. Not smelling the citrus, and only the barest hint of the vanilla. I'm not a fan of intense, smell you before I see you perfumes, but I do want to be able to smell what I'm wearing. My hubby could only smell this when he was close to my skin, and that was only 15 minutes after two good sprays.

The scent is ok. It doesn’t stay on.

This was a unique scent. I enjoyed it. As others noted, the scent did not last long.

i really liked the smell of the perfume but it did not last as long as my other one. the sent smells very unique to all the other i have received!