I LOVE this perfume. I like the entire Clean line of perfumes. I bought Clean Rain, Cool Cotton, Fresh Laundry, Air, Warm Cotton and I will purchase Skin this week. Skin is crisp and fresh. I use Pure and Amazing Grace from Philosophy. I believe the previous reviewer may like the Grace fragrances and Air, Cool & Warm Cotton, and Fresh Laundry. If she didn't like Skin, I don't think she will like Rain. Hope this is helpful.